Skip to main content

Senate witness deserves protection

By Alfredo C. Garvida Jr.

Edgar Matobato, the grade-one-only educated star witness of Sen. Leila De Lima on her ongoing war with President Rodrigo Duterte, gave a disturbing, graphic view of his past involvement and knowledge of crimes committed during the president's mayoral incumbency in Davao City for more than 20 years. He claims to have been employed by Duterte as a member of the Davao Death Squad (DDS) tasked to executing extra-judicially suspected criminals roaming in this largest and most prosperous city in Mindanao. He claimed that more than one thousand criminal suspects had died in the hands of the DDS—upon orders of Mr. Duterte.

At one point, he described how they fed a suspect alive to a crocodile, which made my daughter, who was watching the news with me, almost vomit. Then he related that the President had ordered the murder of his sister's lover some years back because the victim was continuously mulcting his sister. He also revealed that incumbent Davao City vice mayor Paolo Duterte, the President's son, had ordered the death of a guy over his rivalry with him on a woman. His revelations seemed to be comprehensive, yet he appeared credible if his unfaltering narration of events were our measure to his truthfulness—his very lowly educational attainment notwithstanding. To complete the "morbidity" of Duterte's past dispositions, he said that the president also ordered the bombing of a mosque in Davao City back in 2003.

It is worth noting however that Mr. Matobato admitted that he was not present during the commission of the crime on the sister's lover's death, neither was he present during the murder of Paolo's romantic rival, nor was he at the mosque bombing. His testimony about these events therefore are, as Paolo has correctly labeled, hearsay, and will not hold water in a court of law. But these are disturbing revelations if only in the context of Mr. Duterte's reputation as the Charles Bronson of the Philippines. Charles Bronson played a role in a movie series as a cop who would take the shorter route to justice by killing the criminal instead of giving him his day in court. But Mr. Bronson did not kill his subject for personal reasons, and this is where Mr. Duterte separates from him—if Mr. Matobato's testimony on the President's involvement on the lover boy's murder is true. Then there is this Paolo case; his romantic rival died on Paolo's personal reasons, although the President had nothing to do with it, as the witness admitted.

Clearly, the personally motivated killings, along with the mosque bombing and the crocodile feeding are testified in episodes built by the President's enemies to paint a more comprehensive picture of how callous, unforgiving, bigoted and sadist the President is. It is seen as a calculated move by Ms. De Lima and company to undermine Mr. Duterte's unorthodox and populist approach of dealing with criminals, which catapulted him to the presidency by the way, and which is still endearing him with his people.

Of course Mr. Duterte's boys readily came into the counter attack. Sen. Panfilo Lacson, himself an accused, once upon a time, of extra-judicial killings during his stint with the Philippine National Police as commanding general of the crime-busting Task Force Habagat—highlighted by the infamous Kuratong Baleleng Massacre—had elicited some inconsistencies in Matobato's testimonies when he cross-examined him, but the inconsistencies were minor, in this writer's view, to wipe out entirely the witness' narration of events. Then, Sen. Alan Cayetano, a non-member of the senate hearing committee, bombarded the grade-one-only educated witness with rhetorical questions that not even certain elementary graduates could answer, for the sole purpose of telling the audience that Mr. Matobato's testimony was part of a grand plan by the "yellow" cabal of politicians to oust Mr. Duterte and get Vice President Leni Robredo to take his place so that the Liberal Party would again wrest control of the government. Then, we have House Speaker Pantaleon Alvarez proclaiming in advance of a forthcoming House inquiry where top drug personalities now in prison will directly link Ms. De Lima to the drug trade. Then, also came them cabinet members coming in droves to attack this poor witness in defense of Mr. Duterte and obscuring the issue by attacking De Lima's motive. Then there is our bar-topnotcher Senate President Aquilino "Koko" Pimentel III, the president of the PDP, Mr. Duterte's party, who readily dismissed Mr. Matobato's petition for senate protection, as other senate witnesses past, were accorded with.

This writer had called for Ms. De Lima's resignation from the senate in our article three issues back for the simple reason that for having admitted personally her dalliance with a married man, we deemed her unfit to advocate and pursue justice in the senate given the unlawfulness of her relationship with her lover, who was tagged, incidentally also, as the grand bridge between her and the drug bigwigs who were calling their shots inside prison, where they were incarcerated. We are not withdrawing from our call for the lady senator's resignation because Ms. De Lima, in our view, has no ascendancy to talk about justice and lawfulness on account of her adulterous past. But it would seem that for her to leave now would not do justice to all Filipinos in the midst of this disturbing testimony of Mr. Matobato about our President.

Whereas the citizenry is entitled to the truth, it is also of utmost importance to let this inquiry conclude to a legitimate end: because the senate hearing is not a prosecution proceeding but one made in aid of legislation. Therefore, it is beside the point whether the witness is telling the truth or not. What matters is for the senate to listen to testimonies about scenarios that had and could transpire so that congress may make corrective measures to address them if need be.

As it stands today, Mr. Matobato's testimony is pure hearsay—because there are no collaborating testimonies or evidence as yet presented. We may never know if he is a paid witness, but his revelations are extremely disturbing that they have put a heavy dent on our political culture and damaged considerably too our president's reputation. This writer is leaning toward dismissing his testimony as untrue, because it is just his words at this point that I can rely on. The President's honor is on the line, and our national pride and resiliency are under test as well because of this witness' revelations. We ought to go the extra mile to finding out his truthfulness or falsity up to where a legitimate end of this senate inquiry will terminate.


Therefore, we want Mr. Matobato to be kept safe while this inquiry goes on, if only to satisfy my burning desire that my president is innocent from this witness' accusations. Mr. Koko Pimentel's rejection to provide him senate protection, as other witnesses before him had enjoyed, therefore, is incorrect; at best, it smacks of statesmanship-deficiency at his end.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Empanada festival: A celebration of good taste and good life

By Dominic B. dela Cruz & Leilanie G. Adriano Staff reporters BATAC CITY—If there is one thing Batac is truly proud of, it would be its famous empanada-making business that has nurtured its people over the years. Embracing a century-old culture and culinary tradition, Batac’s empanada claims to be the best and tastiest in the country with its distinctive Ilokano taste courtesy of its local ingredients: fresh grated papaya, mongo, chopped longganisa, and egg. The crispy orange wrapper and is made of rice flour that is deep-fried. The celebration of this city’s famous traditional fast food attracting locals and tourists elsewhere comes with the City Charter Day of Batac every 23 rd  of June. Every year, the City Government of Batac led by Mayor Jeffrey Jubal Nalupta commemorate the city’s charter day celebration to further promote its famous One-Town, One Product, the Batac empanada. Empanada City The Batac empanada festival has already become an annua

PIDS expert says income tax cuts justified; warns gov’t of revenue loss

Proposals to amend the personal income tax schedule appear to be well-justified. However, these proposals should include measures that will allow government to recover the revenue loss from lower income taxes. Dr. Rosario Manasan, senior research fellow of state think-tank Philippine Institute for Development Studies (PIDS), said at a seminar sponsored by the Philippine Senate, that government should look for new revenue measures to compensate for the projected revenue loss that will arise as a result of the implementation of any of the various proposals to restructure the personal income tax. Currently, there are several income tax reform proposals pending in both houses of Congress. All of them, according to Dr. Manasan, have the same objective of addressing the phenomenon of bracket creep, which results from “non-indexation to inflation of personal income tax brackets”. Simply put, bracket creep occurs when employees’ income increases over time as a result of inflation. Th

PGIN honors Ilocano heroes of past, present through Heroes Walk

SPO1 Allan Lampitoc Franco of Banna, Ilocos Norte and PO2 Jovalyn D. Lozano of Adams, Ilocos Norte receive a resolution of commendation, a certificate of college scholarship grant to their family members and a P20,000 cash incentive each from the Provincial Government of Ilocos Norte represented by Governor Imee R. Marcos and Vice Governor Angelo M. Barba in recognition of their bravery and heroic acts in the Mamasapano clash in Maguindanao on January 25. Mr. Franco and Mr. Lozano were recognized on March 10 in time for the unveiling of the second batch of Ilocano heroes at the Heroes Walk located along the Sirib Mile in Laoag City.  (Lei Adriano) By Jennifer T. Pambid PGIN-CMO In honor of the heroes who brought freedom, fame and glory to the province as well as to the country in the past century, the Provincial Government of Ilocos Norte (PGIN) through the Education Department and Sirib Youth Office launched the second batch of Ilocano Heroes Walk on March 10, 2015.